0

Is it illegal to take the story of someone who told your story and tell it in your own way?

Let's imagine an alternative Universe. In that universe, I am George Martin, creator of Games of Thrones, I signed a deal and HBO hired 3 people to write 20 seasons, my books cover only the first 10 seasons, so HBO writes the 10 missing ones, and then I decide to take the story told in the other 10 seasons and use the same story to complete my book series.

Can I get sued for that? Taking the script as it is for the 10 later seasons and using it to complete the book series seems like a copyright infringement, but I am wondering how the law would treat cases like these.

What should George Martin from the alternate universe do? How much can George Martin take from the second half of the story, not written by him?

1

1 Answer 1

1

The alternate universe George Martin should have negotiated this in the licensing deal with alternate universe HBO.

(IANAL, but IIUC)
You have copyright over the original work, and granted someone a license to make derivative works. The people that made that derivative work have copyright on anything new they create. Therefore you cannot use that work without getting a license in return (which could be automatic via a clause in the license you granted them).

I suspect the same thing still holds if someone creates derivative work without a license (i.e you can't use their work without a license, even though they weren't allowed to make it in the first place). But since they can't do anything with their derivative work, you have a stronger negotiating position to work something out.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.