I sent a manuscript for a textbook to a publisher 2 months ago. I've not heard anything back at all.

Though the publisher's process of fully accepting a manuscript can take up to 6 months, they say they usually reach out to writers letting them know the work is being considered within 1 month. Since I haven't heard back, I plan to revise the manuscript and find a different publisher. Is it acceptable to first contact the first publisher to double-check they have indeed rejected it?

  • I'd be willing to say it probably depends on how you'd prefer to appear to your publisher, and it probably depends on the publisher too... but I'm not experienced enough to be willing to write an answer. You should probably also consider what you'd do if both publishers accept the two versions of the manuscript Commented Mar 29, 2022 at 16:56
  • 1
    Another option is to first finish your revision, and then contact the publisher to see if they're still considering the manuscript and, if so, would like the revised version.
    – user54131
    Commented Mar 29, 2022 at 17:50

1 Answer 1


I'd see nothing wrong with that. They say "usually", so it isn't certain.

Just say you'd like to know if your manuscript is under consideration, so you can solicit other publishers if it is not.

If it is worth their time, they will answer you. If it isn't they will probably tell you so.

Give them a few weeks to respond, and proceed with soliciting other publishers. If anybody comes back with a deal, then you can cancel the process with other publishers.

I don't know the process of textbook publishing, but certainly when looking to publish fiction, you approach a handful of agents or publishers at a time, and take the first deal that comes.

Only a handful, not dozens or hundreds. The reason for that is if you get rejected by the handful and they are kind enough to provide any criticism, you can address their criticisms and try again. Not with them, but with fresh agents. You don't want to approach everybody, get rejected by everybody, and the few that offer any criticism are united and it is something you can fix.

I'd put your own time limit on how long they have to respond before you go ahead and solicit another publisher. They say a month, you've given them two, I personally would just move on and submit to the next.

If the first finally expresses interest, stay engaged, tell them when you didn't hear from them you reached out to others, but you would like to work toward a commitment. Be honest but don't make promises of exclusivity and don't burn any bridges. Your goal is to get published, you don't owe anybody loyalty until you have their signature on a contract.

For example, if your first choice comes back with interest, and you cancel with your second choice, and then your first choice decides against making an offer -- What do you tell your second choice? Please take me back? I didn't mean it?

It's like dating. You're on the market. You're talking to lots of guys. Don't take yourself off the market until they put a ring on it.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.