What should I do when I write an idea, for example a fight scene, but then I find it difficult to write a solution or way to switch from that idea? Should I cancel the whole idea or what, knowing that I have no outline before for that story but I just started writing it. It's kind of a weird question but I hope that there is a solution and an answer for it 😔

  • Fighting Schimting, This is about writing technique, the technical aspects of writing, not tech writing. Jul 10, 2020 at 15:47
  • @Alexander perhaps you could express this in a more supportive way. It helps new contributors feel welcome and learn more.
    – rolfedh
    Jul 12, 2020 at 14:25

5 Answers 5


When I come to a problem like this I usually write a list of all the characters, ideas, scenes and other things I want to include in my story. Like this:

  • Include a battle scene between _____ and _____.
  • Add a character called ______.
  • Use a twist were _________.

And so on...

Anyway, after I've done that I try and piece them together like a puzzle as Rolfedh said before. If I can't think of a good way to piece together some ideas I would:

  1. Look at how other authors use the idea.
  2. Take a break.
  3. Get input from a family member or a friend (two brains are better than one!).

I hope this helps but if in the end none of this works out I suggest slightly altering the idea/scene/character so it's still slightly like the first idea but different. Example: A fight scene with magic becomes a fight scene without magic, a physical war between two enemies becomes a verbal one.


Don't toss them out; collect them!

What you've got there is a story fragment. You can start a collection of story fragments. Chances are, your fragments are a constellation of related ideas. As you write and collect them, you might start seeing connections between them. Then you can write those in-between connecting parts and assemble them into a larger story.

  • Agreed many writers combined different idea fragments to create something greater than the sum of its parts Jul 12, 2020 at 13:53

What I do is write the idea itself. By the time I have done that a solution or the next idea usually suggests itself. If it doesn't, I go for a walk and try putting random ideas or words together to find a solution.

In the rare case that these don't work, I revise something else I have written and then come back to the piece. At this point I sit there until I have something sensible to write, or, very rarely, decide that the idea can't be progressed.


Do not worry, give it some time.

If you have what seems to be a good idea, your mind won't let it go. Eventually you will either build a story around it, or, while working on some other story, you'll discover that the new story and old idea would actually go pretty well together.

Don't settle for a bad story around a good idea. Let it work through.


Use a structural template to fit it in

If you're into some structure in your writing, I'd suggest using a structural template like a Story Circle, and then using that to find a natural spot for your bit of conflict in some broader narrative.

The Story Circle is a simplification of the Hero's Journey as specified by Joseph Campbell, further developed by Dan Harmon (of Community/Rick and Morty fame): it splits stories into 8 themed chunks that when put together make for a narrative that is easy to follow and satisfying to read or see or hear. It's a simple template for telling any kind of story in a way that is immediately familiar to most people.

The parts of the circle are shown here:

story circle

Each part of the circle can also be subdivided into a smaller, "nested" story circle, if your target length demands more content for the overarching story. I've had success fitting similar fragments of narrative into larger projects by looking at what part of the circle the particular story fragment naturally fits into.

For example, sections 3, 4 and 6 often contain conflict (especially the hero getting defeated in some way in 4 or 6) so those could be good spots to try to fit in a fight scene.

For more information, there is also a simple video on YouTube from adult swim where he summarizes it.

  • What is great, is he does this for even tiny character arcs. This is most notable in the butter robot. The butter robot passes through all these in Rick and Morty. Jul 10, 2020 at 15:45

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.