1

Is a story about the Hindu gods being real inherently copyright infringing on the Percy Jackson series? Is a story about a plague causing the apocalypse, then a street gang trying to restore order and government (without time travel) copyright infringing on 12 monkeys?

  • I once kept a list of ideas I had had which were "stolen" by much, much better known writers. In some cases that freed me from obligation of having to write them. Ideas are not copyright. They belong to all writers. Besides your version will always be yours. So go for it – a4android Feb 7 '20 at 4:37
  • Hindu gods aren't copyright nor are apocalypse causing plagues. 12 Monkeys was a time travel story based on Chris Marker's La Jetee. This was well known and using the same core idea wasn't a copyright infringement. – a4android Feb 7 '20 at 4:40
4

The premise of a story is not copyright infringement.

Here are some known stories that comes to mind:

  • A young male ant falls in love with the princess and has to save the whole colony. (Antz and A Bug's Life)

  • A comet is on collision course with Earth and a team is sent to nuke it. (Armageddon and Deep Impact)

  • A man arrives in a new world looking for riches, but falls in love
    with a native woman and decides to fight for her people. (Avatar and Pocahontas)

As long as your plot and worldbuilding is different from where you found your inspiration, I don't see how that would be a problem. Nothing's unique anymore. Or at least so rare that even great authors have borrowed heavily from others.

Tolkien's The Lord of The Rings (Der Ring des Nibelungen)

Stephen King's "The Shawshank Redemption" (Leo Tolstoy’s short story "God Sees the Truth But Waits")

Sir Arthur Conan Doyle's Sherlock Holmes (Edgar Allan Poe's character C. Auguste Dupin)

Happy writing!

  • 1
    A male ant falling in love with a princess and having to save the colony is bad biology. Male ants are winged drones and only exist to fertilize the queen. They barely live long enough to do that, let alone have time to save the colony. Otherwise a good answer. Plus one. – a4android Feb 7 '20 at 4:29
  • @a4android Much appreciated. The premises I mentioned are all from known movies/animated movies. I'll edit to make it clear. – OldBat Feb 7 '20 at 12:30
  • I assumed they were from well-known movies, though not necessarily that well-known to yours truly, it's just that some premises can be plain wrong. I am afraid I couldn't help myself from pointing out their wrongness. Naughty old me! – a4android Feb 7 '20 at 22:11
2

Every idea in fiction has been used to some extent a bunch of times. I've thought of ideas and had them be in Percy Jackson specifically, actually, also (so I feel your pain).

Personally, I say you're fine. You reference Hindu gods, first of all, which, to my understanding, are very different from Greek, Egyptian, or any gods Rick Riordan has used in his books. He makes the gods interact directly with demigods and humans (kind of), and gives them senses of humor, makes them engage in petty arguments, etc. You could, hypothetically, involve the Hindu gods very differently. As long as you aren't basing anything off of something else, you can throw in your own flavor and make it original.

Same for your second idea - especially since 12 Monkeys' story relies heavily on time travel (god, that was a tripped-out movie...). And if you're really worried about it, maybe you could have someone read what you've written and see if they draw any direct parallels.

Your ideas sound cool. Good luck!

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.