2

I was wondering if "Spear" or "The Spear" could be the name of a planet. But I can't find a single reason to name a planet that way, and even if there were it just sounds horribly stupid. What are the general rules and principles you should to follow to name non-living things?

6
  • 2
    I think this question could very easily become on topic if it were about strategies for naming general geographical features in general (from valleys and mountains, to continents, planets and stars). Tips on how to name characters are often asked for, but naming geographical features is trickier and a lot of writers could do with some orientation. – SC for reinstatement of Monica Jan 30 '19 at 14:27
  • 2
    Are you thinking of giving this name to a planet in a story that you're writing? But why, if you think the name is "horribly stupid"? Or did you find this name in someone else's story? What's the background to this question? – Jay Jan 30 '19 at 14:48
  • I thought that I would name a planet "The Spear", because it had a massive mountain range shaped like a spear. – puffofsmoke Jan 30 '19 at 15:05
  • 2
    Might be worth mentioning who is talking about the planet (natives or outside observers), and who named it that way. Essentially whether it is a far away blip in the sky (like calling some planet after a god because you think that's where gods live) or the land under our boot (like calling the planet for a synonym of soil) kind of deal. – AmiralPatate Jan 30 '19 at 15:41
  • 1
    @AmiralPatate Yes, also whether this name is meant to be "official" or not and to whom. – called2voyage Jan 30 '19 at 15:45
3

In human languages, most translations of the Earth are just "the Earth", or "the World", or "the Land". Once in a while, you will find a proper name ("Gaia") of a God, or a reference to a God ("God's House"). The same is probably true of the Sun; the sun is the sun, it is just a label everyone understands, and knows what it means. There doesn't have to be any deeper mythological reason.

In all those cases, the planet is singular; they need a name to refer to a singular object, so it makes no difference what it is.

Your name would need some mythological reason involving OTHER planets in order to distinguish THIS planet from them, some reason THIS planet is something as specific as "The Spear" and other planets are presumably named after other objects. Perhaps its role in an interplanetary war.

3

This is a chart of the stars in the Ursa Major:

enter image description here

And here, straight out from Wikipedia, is an explanation of the name "Tania Borealis", given to the star also known as Lambda Ursae Majoris:

It bore the traditional names Tania (shared with Mu Ursae Majoris) and Tania Borealis. Tania comes from the Arabic phrase Al Fiḳrah al Thānia 'the Second Spring (of the Gazelle)'.[14] and Borealis (originally borealis[15]) is Latin for 'the north side'. In 2016, the International Astronomical Union organized a Working Group on Star Names (WGSN)[16] to catalog and standardize proper names for stars. The WGSN's first bulletin of July 2016[17] included a table of the first two batches of names approved by the WGSN; which included Tania Borealis for this star.

In Chinese, 三台 (Sān Tái), meaning Three Steps, refers to an asterism consisting of Lambda Ursae Majoris, Iota Ursae Majoris, Kappa Ursae Majoris, Mu Ursae Majoris, Nu Ursae Majoris and Xi Ursae Majoris. Consequently, Lambda Ursae Majoris itself is known as 中台一 (Zhōng Tái yī, English: Star of First Middle Step).[18]

So, what do we have here? A single star with at least three names spanning four languages and cultures: the modern Lambda Ursae Majoris, the arabic Thānia, the latin adjective Borealis, and the chinese Zhōng Tái yī.

There is a reason and a sort of method behind those names, but after all they are arbitrary. Citing from the Working Group on Star Names guidelines:

"Names preserving world heritage are strongly encouraged; common and cultural names preferred over new"

So, they are mostly heritage. A lot of star have arabic names because the Arab culture gave rise to many great astronomers. Had they been Finnish, we would be using Finnish name. And of course, almost every culture in history had its own name for the most relevant star; today we're talking about just the ones that "stuck around".

This said, there is no valid reason why "The Spear" should be less plausible than Star of First Middle Step or the Second Spring.

I'm aware that you are talking about a planet, but it makes little difference. The choice of names for celestial bodies, if we are not talking about highly scientific names, is often a matter of culture. The planet Venus was often called "Vesper Star" because it was mistaken for a star which appeared in the evenings. And after all the common name Venus is no better, being the ancient latin name for a goddess.

There might be a particular astronomical configuration where your planet appears "as the tip of a spear", hence the name, without even having to dabble with mythology.

Just think about where or why this name came from in your wordlbuilding. If the explanation makes sense, the name will make sense and will eventually sound familiar to the reader, as much as "canis major" or "ursa minor" or "polaris star" are today. If you need to name an entire constellation, thought, you may want to look at what astronomers did.

A whole constellation full of unique names will fill your sky of impossible-to-remember stars, while astronomers, as scientist, will try to give names under a convention or a mnemonic method. But truth to be told, you probably don't need to wordlbuild this far on the topic.

2

I would say that it's nowhere near as crazy as some of the other planet names that are out there.

However, I think you should put your writing creativity cap on and come up with a good reason for calling it that - something related to your story and the history of the people in it.

Perhaps there was a great war of the ancestors, and a mighty goddess threw her spear in a rage and it flew so high it stuck in the sky, where you can still see it to this day.

2

Hill 937 site of the battle of hamburger hill.

Remember there is an infinite number of galaxies. And in each a nearly infinite number of star systems, each with many stars and that many more planets.

There are many many possible ways to do it...

Off the top of my head... you could divide the milky way into zones (the thing is about 100,000 light years across) 360 degrees on the XY plane, 360 on the YZ plane 050-072-503-E67X-5512k

50 degree the XY plane

72 degree on the YZ plane

503 between 503000 and 504000 light years from the center.

E67X System identifier

5512k stars-planet-moon..

My point is.. given the infinite cosmos... Earthlings would only name a planet if there is any significance at all to them. I would imagine the same would go for other spacefaring species.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.