I remember reading this somewhere, though I cannot remember the source:

When working on the 2nd draft, read through the 1st draft, looking for holes. But then throw it away, and rewrite the the 2nd draft from scratch. This will make you a better writer, and also make writing the 2nd draft easy, as you don't have to fix a broken piece of work.

Is there any truth to this? Should we try to "fix" the 1st draft, or start from scratch again?

1 Answer 1


This depends on the writer. You should try both ways to figure out what is the best for you.

One source for this redrafting concept is Dean Wesley Smith (don't miss the second part). Smith distinguishes "rewriting" (fixing a draft) and "redrafting" (start from scratch). His main issue against rewriting is, that most authors tend to rewrite to death and he has a point here. That's why you have to compare your rewrites with the original text (and let others compare them) to not fall into this trap. If you revised the originality out of your text, you are in trouble.

But nonetheless I suggest to rewrite your draft, if you are a beginner. Smith tells you, that you shouldn't do it, but I guess he did it in the past and he learnt his lesson. And that's my point. If you haven't done it, if you have not experienced when a rewrite is an improvement and when it is written to death, you cannot make the choice, if redrafting or rewriting suits you better.

Try both concepts out and keep in mind what Smith says over and over again: No writer is the same.

  • 2
    +1 for two excellent points: every writer is different, and you won't know if it works for you unless you try it. Jul 27, 2011 at 20:39

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.