Post Deleted by Community
    Post Locked by Community
    Post Migrated Away to literature.stackexchange.com by Mark Baker, Chris Sunami, F1Krazy, Secespitus, Neil Fein
    Post Closed as "off-topic" by Mark Baker, Chris Sunami, F1Krazy, Secespitus, Neil Fein
2 Add tag "poetry"
| link
1
source | link

Examples of "good bad poetry" (as defined by George Orwell)

Recently I bumped into an article where "The Poetry Foundation’s president, John Barr, takes a look at what separates “serious” poetry from the rest". Poetry being an art form, obviously no such definition will ever satisfy everyone, nor should it, but I still found the distinction made in the article interesting and worthy of consideration.

Yes, there is plenty of poorly written verse out there, but there is also plenty of poorly written poetry—and sometimes the verse is the better crafted.

Robert Service’s “The Cremation of Sam McGee,” with no help from the critical establishment, is still going strong after a century, while most early Yeats is read today only because it was written by Yeats. To use verse as a pejorative term, then, is to lose the use of it as a true distinction.

George Orwell gives us another way to think about this when he describes Kipling as “a good bad poet.”

”A good bad poem is a graceful monument to the obvious. It records in memorable form—for verse is a mnemonic device, among other things—some emotion which very nearly every human being can share.”

Into this same pot Orwell puts “The Charge of the Light Brigade,” the work of Bret Harte—and presumably that of Robert Service. “There is a great deal of good bad poetry in English,” says Orwell; by implication, there is even more bad bad poetry.

What other well-known examples of such "good bad poetry" are there? Are there other concepts or names for this kind of thing, that might make the search easier?